April 24, 2013

Bankrupted Cities: The Easy Out Usually Leads Back In

Cities are like businesses, according to David Unkovic, who worked in business for 30 years before becoming a Harrisburg, Pennsylvania receiver. They get into fiscal trouble when their revenue streams run dry, spending gets out of control, capital improvements are delayed, debt and liabilities mount, and cash runs out. Ok, but haven’t we heard all of this before?
Yes, but Unkovic’s analysis shows just how complicated the plot really is. In a paper he presented last March at the Bond Buyer Symposium on Distressed Municipalities in Providence, he described how quick fixes to short-term problems ultimately compound the problem. Sounds like the law of unintended consequences.

Exactly! For example, revenues flow sporadically in municipalities that rely heavily on property taxes, which are usually paid once or twice a year. Financially sound municipalities can close the gap by drawing on their reserves or taking out a line of credit. But what do financially distressed municipalities do? “They get desperate,” Unkovic wrote. ”Maybe they improperly charge for unrelated services, maybe they deplete assets, maybe they incur lots of debt and use the money for current services, maybe they do an interest rate swap for upfront money, and maybe they stretch out their payments to vendors.”

Unkovic didn’t say if he saw the same things in business. But, in the Fifth Discipline, a business book on organizational problem solving, Peter Senge described how “the long-term, most insidious consequence of applying nonsystemic solutions is increased need for more and more of the solution.” Short-term fixes often overlook how problems evolved. “Underlying all of the above problems is a fundamental characteristic of complex human systems: ‘cause’ and ‘effect’ are not close in time and space.”

Unkovic might agree with these generalizations. As he wrote, “The primary cause of municipal distress is that the system is often rigged under state law so that the revenue/expenses/assets/liabilities/cash flow of certain municipalities simply do not work, and the desperate short term measures then taken by desperate municipal officials make matters worse and worse.”